â€å“look

Though we've all ranted and raved about the MacBook Air since Tuesday's launch at MacWorld, i think we're not getting any closer to a final decision. Many people see this incredibly thin machine as an ideal travel laptop, while I think Apple got so caught up in its focus on thinness that sacrificed far too many other features. Some argue that this is a typical Apple move to kill off unnecessary features ahead of the rest of the industry, but I don't think that's what's going on here. There's a lot on my mind, but I'll use some reader comments to get into it.

Brendan West: But if they had a super-thin bezel, the edges of the computer could not reach that mythical 0.16″³, you see. The thinning of the shell means the still-pretty-bulky-for-its-size-LCD screen has to stop at a certain thickness.

With the MacBook, the bezel was so thick (I think) because of the emerging magnetic latch tech. With the MBA, it's because (I think) they just couldn't do it, cap'n.

That's all true, but why does going down to 0.16″ matter? Any laptop is going to take up as much space as its thickest component. Apple couldn't have gotten 0.25″ and gotten a better-looking bezel and bigger screen in the process?

Anon: "It's still bigger than a 12″³ Powerbook." And not just a little bigger. It's two inches wider. I just measured, it won't fit in the laptop bag that totes around my four year old Powerbook. I agree with all the Air's compromises (speed, ports, I can even live with the integrated battery.) But the huge footprint is probably a dealbreaker. It means the Air's thickness and weight is more about looks then portability. I've had one Powerbook after another for the last 15 years, but I'm worried: I don't see my next machine in Apple's lineup.

You and me both.

Bone: Hey, Pete"¦

When you get that masters in product design / mechanical and electrical engineering maybe you can explain to Apple's designers/engineers how to fit an 8mm thick 1.8 HD where a 5MM thick version probably barely fits and keep the thing just as thin. Same goes with the bezel.

So long as they can tell me why shaving off that 3mm is more important than providing an $1800 laptop that would have as much storage as a $349 portable media player, I'm ready to have that conversation. Three millimeters is 0.11 inches. Oh noes! The MacBook Air might be 0.76″ in more places than its hinge! Call the cops!

Ian: I also looked at my kids needs. We have wi-fi at home and they mostly use their Mac now for iPod and Thumb drive. The last time my kids listened to a CD or watched a movie on the Macbook was an age ago. They don't know what a Firewire cable is and so will not miss it. So I think this is a great product for students as well. It is targeted at a different market"¦

An interesting perspective. I can't say I disagree.

Greg Baines: It is no doubt a beautiful machine. But I was just looking at the Hong Kong apple site, and I worked out for around the same price as the air I could buy an iMac, Apple TV, and an iPod touch.

If I really needed a portable and walked intot he Hong Kong store with the money for an air, I could by an iBook, an iPod touch, an iPod classic, and an Apple TV for the price of an air.

I'd love to buy one, but it just costs too much. What a shame. With all these really decent low cost machiens coming out (but poorly designed), why couldn't apple also bring something simple and beautifuly designed that people actually need? What about the education market?

Maybe we should all boycott the Macbook Air- it is no doubt the most beautiful computer ever made, but why do we get pushed overpriced products all the time?

That's a bit extreme, but I agree in part. What about the education market?

Finally, I wanted to take quotes from two celebrity commentators on the MacBook Air: Wil Shipley, founder of Delicious Monster, and Steve Jobs himself. They're both fans.

Shipley : I don't buy a laptop because I want to replace its drive in a year. I buy it because it seems great and meets my needs today. If my needs magically morph over the coming year, I guess I'll sell it on eBay. Or pay Apple to throw in a different drive, or something. Honestly, I think we need to admit that just because machines get faster every year, doesn't mean that the majority of people need faster machines.

In two weeks I'll be writing Delicious Library 2 on a MacBook Air, every day. Because it's simple and beautiful, and I crave those things.

Well, obviously, Wil, but my 12″ Powerbook G4 is nearly five years old, and I don't think Apple is interested in putting it back on the market as an executive laptop. Besides, people do constantly need more data storage as video editing, photo editing, podcasting and other kinds of creativity got democratized — mostly thanks to Apple's iLife suite. I have a really hard time believing that your Air isn't going to spend most of its time at home hooked up with either a server or NAS, Wil. Right now, 80 gigs isn't enough for anyone really interested in maintaining a big iTunes library and adding TV and movies into the mix, as well. It just isn't. There's no getting around this issue. And ordinary people don't have external hard drives, home servers or other such solutions.

Jobs : "I'm going to be the first one in line to buy one of these," he said. "I've been lusting after this."

Yep. Just as I suspected. Steve made a machine for himself, as ever. It's just a shame that this time his view of the world was so vastly different from the realities most of us have to deal with. He lives in Palo Alto, where WiFi is ubiquitous, so forget about a 3G modem on the Air. He has a million external data storage options and more powerful computers at his disposal, so keep the hard drive tiny. He won't buy the one with a regular hard drive, so throw in a slow, unreliable iPod hard drive instead of a real one. The rich people like Steve will all buy the one with the SSD in it, so who cares about the low end?

At the end of the day, this is my take on the MacBook Air: Gorgeous design solving a questionable goal of ultimate thinness. The model with the SSD is a dream secondary computer for the rich and famous. The other one is going to be unsatisfying to a lot of people. Most importantly, it's just not small enough. Who decided that thin was the only way to go about making a full-featured laptop that doesn't weigh much? And the 12″ Powerbook still hasn't been topped as a design triumph at Apple. Period.

armstrongunclefor.blogspot.com

Source: https://www.cultofmac.com/1676/macbook-air-the-final-word-at-least-for-now/

Share this post